Would you do this trade?

Not at all. Yes, Miguel Cabrera is an amazing hitter, but he also has off-the-field issues that could cause him to miss time this year. Alex Rios is a 5-category producer, do not trade him. Tim Hudson could be traded, as he has injury issues and had a stellar season last year. Jayson Werth could have a bust season this year. Trade instead of Alex Rios Jason Bay if you can.